Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Horus on the Prairie's avatar

I hesitate comparing the ancient world to modern politics, especially bronze and iron ages agrarian feudal monarchies to current representative republics. Two giant political parties in the US encompassing so many issues and factions, in a system that does not include the possibility of coalition governments, means it will be difficult to group any platform or politician under a single archetype.

So it is with Donald Trump. On one hand he certainly is a bull in a china shop, with ideas that clash with the DC establishment policy and norms, resulting in political and legal conflicts borne out through bombastic speeches and mutual accusations. Yet in other respects he isn't: part of his platform was restoring law and order at home and abroad, including border security, all things his voters felt had spiraled into chaos. The border wall project may be seen as a giant Migdol fortress, and many of his speeches remind me of Pharaohs who talk about restoring temples that had fallen into ruin, or the Admonitions of Ipuwer lamenting rampant disorder in society.

Certainly his opponents see him as Apep, and I am unfamiliar with any literature describing Apep as having anything positive, even necessary change. For them he is the unraveling of all things good and beneficial, a return to dark times left behind, a rebel against proper order and its progression. To his supporters, I would say he is more like Sekhmet, perhaps Sobek or even Set (before his demonization in the Late Period). These deities were fighters whose disruption was put to beneficial ends against agents of chaos, but had to be handled very carefully, like the creatures who symbolized them. In this respect they view Trump's opponents as the priesthood viewed Akhenaten: not as valid authorities but as agents of chaos who took power and were steering things on wrong track.

A thought provoking post for sure.

Expand full comment

No posts